Portugal Day Race - 11th June 2011
Last updated on
Above: Weather systems gone awry. That's the smoke from the Cape Doctors pipe billowing over Table Mountain. Nothing unusual about that except that it's mid-winter!
Photo: Trevor Wilkins
Race in a nutshell: 11th June, 2011
Position PHRF : 26th
Total entries : 62
Distance: 16 nm.
Max Speed: 15.8 knots
Ave speed: 6.5 knots
Weather Forecast: Clear. Wind SE 5 to 10 knots. Temp 20C
Weather Actual: Clear. Wind SE 22 knots
Course: 10 (P) – Paarden island (P) - Milnerton (P) - Celi 1 (S) - Milnerton (S) Red mark finish (S)
Seas: Choppy 1.0m
Sails: Full Main (Quantum), No. 1 Genoa (Quantum), No. 2 Genoa (Quantum), R1 Assymetric (Quantum)
Crew: Trygve Roberts (Helm), Phillip Rentschler (Main), Charles Crosby (Genoa/Spinnaker), Simon Penso (Pit), Shereen Smith (Mast), Joshua Banks (Bow), : Total: 485 kg
This annual race attracts a large entry. Like the Mykonos Offshore, it has it's own special allure which is hard to peg down. Is it the fun element; the free food; the folk dancing; the rock band; the Portuguese vibe? Who knows, but the winter hibernators turned up in their droves to participate with a very solid entry of 62 boats. The race is held in the pursuit format (slowest boats start first) and for race organisers this style of racing presents several challenges. So just how do they determine start staggered times based on the length of course and the wind strength, when it keeps changing? In broad terms, pursuit racing has a few advantages.
1. It gives the smaller, slower boats a chance to be in the front of the fleet
2. It presents a challenge for the bigger, faster boats to play catch up and have to endure dirties for a change.
Most people like pursuit racing as it radically changes likely outcomes and often throws in some wildcard results. At coastal venues, the seabreeze generally builds as the day wears on, giving the bigger, faster boats an advantage in that they spend more time sailing in good pressure, but every now and then we get a curved ball thrown into the mix. Saturday was one of those.
Above: Regent Express on the final fetch home - and overpowered.
Photo: Trevor Wilkins
The forecast of a light south easterly was a 50/50 one. The weathermen got the direction right but not the speed. As we cast off from our mooring, we noticed the tell-tale table cloth settling in and dropping over the lip of Table Mountain. That is almost a guaranteed sign of having to change down to a smaller headsail or reef the main. But it's mid-winter! Surely the south easter can't have any real punch? We have a standing joke on our boat that there is no such thing as a light south easterly. The more we sail on Table bay, the more that theory holds true.
We sailed out of the harbour with our big sail plan up in a moderate north westerly. Yes, NW! How that happens is that the wind squeezes around the sides of the bulk of the mountain giving a south easter on the east side and a north wester on the west side. Somewhere in between that lot is the convergence zone, which is of course, calm. And it just so happens that the RCYC fixed starting line oftens lies in that zone. The wind is fickle and sometimes the SE wind is there, sometimes calm and sometimes the NW wind is felt. Starting a race under those conditions is a bit like going to the casino. It is purely luck if there is or isn't breeze in your allotted starting time.
Above: Regent Express in her element going downwind fast.
Photo: Trevor Wilkins
And so it was with our start. We watched in dismay as the fleet ahead of us sailed into the distance as we lay becalmed on the start line. Those few minutes feel like hours. The Melges 24 which was right next to us, picked up a whiff of breeze and got away. Their lead stretched to some 400 meters before we got to the first mark. So basically, our race was blown, before we even got out the starting blocks. But its a fun race, so we dont complain (much!). Yeah right! Our start time was 53 minutes after the first boat over a 16 mile course, so we had a LOT of catching up to do. The good news was that once we were into the south easter proper, we would be able to sustain good downwind speeds and get through the fleet.
After 10 minutes of flopping about in the calm zone, we finally got into the south easterly and settled down into full race format. Immediately after rounding the Paarden Island mark, we got the big asso up and went straight onto the plane and started ticking boats off as we sailed down the coast towards Blouberg. This was just not destined to be our race as the course was a dead run. That meant having to do many gybes down the coast
and with each crossing of the fleet, it was a bit like playing Dodgem cars as we weaved our way behind and in front of bigger boats, but we were making steady progress. One of the things one doesn't pay much attention to in a pursuit race is navigation. Why bother, when we have the entire fleet in front of us to show us precisely where all the marks are? It would turn out that the entire fleet (bar one) would end up sailing the wrong course. It is quite a common scenario around the world. Bah, bah, white sheep.
Above: Some of the fleet dealing with blustery conditions on the final leg
Photo: Trevor Wlkins
We had closed the gap on the Melges and managed to overtake it as well. Abeam Milnerton we started talking about possibly doing a headsail change. On a boat without a twin foil system, this is a lot more difficult than it appears - not to mention time consuming. It takes almost 10 minutes, if you are working fast. Add to that little lot the fact that we are planing along at 15 knots and have to send a bowman to the foredeck, which is (a) very wet and (b) changes the way the boat handles. In short, we think long and hard before making the final decision on a headsail change.
That day, we decided the very long beat back would see us overpowered with a No1 Genoa up, so we sent Josh up front to his thing. He took the first wave full in the face which would have him chattering with a quivering jaw and a bit blue around the mouth an hour later. It's a tough job being bowman! With the headsail change done just in time, we planed past several big boats with very little space to spare, to do the mark rounding of the Celi 1 - a bit of an odd place to have a mark, as it is quite shallow and congested. This would later turn out to be the subject of much embarrassment and even anger for several competitors and some dubious communication in the sailing instructions. But hey - it's just a fun race? Right?
We did a seamanlike rounding and strike and settled down for the long beat back to Milnerton in a stiff 22 knots of south easterly and plenty of chop. Not really ideal conditions for a Pacer 27. The zone around the mark and directly behind the stern of the wreck was messy and tricky with the big fleet coming and going in both directions. Being hemmed in by the bulk of the wreck added to the congestion. It was not a good place to put a mark. Later we were to discover that the mark which everyone thought was the "mark just north of Celi 1" was in fact just a danger mark, to warn mariners of the new sand bank that had developed there. The 52 ft Thunderchild promptly ran aground when she tried rounding the mark. It was a miracle that none of the other deep draft racing boats didn't hit the putty.
Only the L26 "Hors d Ouvers" had correctly interpreted the SI's and sailed another 2 miles further north and located and rounded the correct mark. Imagine the awkward situation for the organisers? Sixty one boats disqualified and one winner of all the prizes? Skipper of the L26, Peter bam, is not only a good sailor, but a good sport as well. He agreed to take average points and for the race results to stand. Well done Peter. That was gentlemanly of you.
Above: Josh, Shereen, Simon and Charles doing the hard yards upwind.
Photo: Trevor Wilkins
The beat back was cold (on a small boat) and more so if you were wet. We looked for all the shifts, but there wasn't much to be had. We were well pleased to be holding our own upwind against the L34's. Before we reached the Milnerton mark, one of our halyard deck blocks burst, sending our jib down to the deck. It took about 5 minutes to jury rig another halyard and get going again. [The block that disintegrated was one of the new generation, expensive, light weight, cheekless carbon blocks. We will replace it with a more robust stainless steel framed unit]
The leg from Milnerton to the finish was a tight fetch and the breeze was building the closer we got to shore. Our finishing place of 26th was about right considering our time spent in the calm zone at the start and the halyard problem. The race was won by the main organiser, Vitor Medina in his Miura "Far Med". For once the smaller boats did well. The big cat "Isla" was smoking on that last fetch. She must have passed more than 20 boats on one leg to sail into 3rd place. Nice to see the multihulls participating!
The festivities were once again held in the shed (with its poor acoustics). Numbers of attendees were well down on previous years. This can no doubt be attributed to (a) the very high volume of noise in the shed. Add a rock band + poor acoustics + 500 happy sailors
and that will account for many having fled for the sanctity of their homes and (b) a Super Rugby game featuring the home team.
So how does one tweak an event that is well attended and a lot of fun? I'm not really sure on this one, but I get the feeling that perhaps it is time to introduce a few changes. The event has followed the same format (of soup and rolls; folk dancing; inaudible speeches; main course; deafeningly loud band; end of all conversation) - for the last 6 years with no change. I think it is time to innovate a little. This year, I was one of those that just couldn't face the noise in the shed, so I left early for home. Perhaps I'm just getting old? Those that did go home early probably improved available space for those that stayed.
Obrigado.
It would be remiss of me not to publish the team results (especially seeing that our team managed to come last) - Like I said "not our finest hour" . The illustrious Vasco da Gama team who were placed 1st last year have had our butts kicked! In the 2010 event, Regent Express scored a 4th from 51. Shweee! How the mighty have fallen.
Team results are listed below the overall results.
Results:
1 | SA1335 | Far Med | Muira | Vitor Medina |
2 | SA2360 | Saoirse | Atlantis 36 | Tony blackwell |
3 | SA 4123 | Isla | Wilderness 1480 | Ian henderson |
4 | GBR 3733R | Jacana | J 133 | Patrick Holloway |
5 | SA797 | Iechyd Da | Miura* | S Hundt |
6 | SA3444 | Maestro | Fast 42 | Paul van Ass |
7 | SA3737 | Windpower | Landmark 43 | R Nankin |
8 | SA 4114 | Necessity | Ben 34.7 | David Booth |
9 | SA 893 | Chen | Muira | M.Saunders |
10 | US43434 | Spilhaus | Swede 55 | Ted Kuttel |
11 | SA66 | Indaba | Stadt 34 | John Levin |
12 | SA2700 | Lobelia | IMX 40 | Rob Meek |
13 | SA3800 | Puma Unleashed | Pacer 42 | Hylton Hale |
14 | SA630 | A-L | Farr 38 | Robbi van Rooyen |
15 | SA858 | Rockstar | Farr 38 mod | Brian Gardener |
16 | SA198 | Hillbilly | J27 | Peter Hill |
17 | 9 | Ray of Light | Ben First 44.7 | Michael Kavanagh |
18 | SA1967 | Storm | Ocean 31 | M Peper |
19 | 010 | Lapwing | L34 | A Keen/J Burger |
20 | SA74 | Ambre | Trimtwas 36 | Larry Davis |
21 | SA3141 | Always Well | First 7.5 | Burger/Thomas |
22 | SA 3786 | Pants on Fire | J 105 | Jorge Dwayne Assis |
23 | SA969 | Corum | Briand43 | Jan Reuvers |
24 | 13 | Ariel | RCOD | Toni de Villiers |
25 | SA2447 | Paragon | Ocean 31 | Ann Fletcher |
26 | 17 | Regent Express | Pacer 27 Sport | Trygve Roberts |
27 | SA250 | Freedom | Farr 38 | C.P Van Der Merwe |
28 | SA2018 | Cabaray | Van der Stadt | Ray Matthews |
29 | SA3740 | Celine IV | Comfortina 39 | V Vierhaus |
30 | SA2954 | Sheshisa | Bav Match 38 | Arnold Sheman |
31 | 047 | Vortex | L34 | Mike Atkins |
32 | 014 | Nuthr Witch | L 34 | Dave Garrard |
33 | 011 | Tally Ho | L 34 | John Waller |
34 | SA818 | Ava | Miura | K Botwood |
35 | SA 223 | Impact | Impact | Tommy Walker |
36 | SA1146 | Cathy R | Compass 47 | J Rabie |
37 | SA978 | Aurora | Atlantic | Mel Hawtrey |
38 | SA1027 | Auto Atlantic Thunderchild | L52 | R Goldswain |
39 | SA1178 | Touch 'n Go | Lightwave 395 | Dave Smith |
40 | SA898 | Me2Me | Farr 38 | D Shuttleworth |
41 | SA917 | Vodoo | Lavarnos 52 mod | Wayne Hemmings |
42 | SA765 | Majimoto II | Farr 40 | Paul Mare/Lindsay Birch |
43 | SA190 | Pure Magic | J27 | A Taylor |
44 | SA410 | Mini Mace | Melges 24 | Nicholas Mace |
45 | SA399 | Paprika | Peterson 33 | Howard Minne |
46 | SA1235 | Sizwe | Muira | Hennie McLaghlan |
47 | SA1326 | Picasso | Sovereign 54 | Ray Alexander |
48 | SA 1011 | Carousel | Benet Oceanis 390 | Luke Scott |
49 | 011 | Southern Cross | Holiday 34 | John Flemming |
50 | SA2996 | Reaction | RCOD | Charl Cilliers |
51 | SA 3615 | Zeal o Cat | Robertson Caine 46 | Ernie Aylard |
52 | SA1839 | Siesta | Flamenca | D.J Griffin |
53 | SA654 | Spindrift | Muira | Rob Brennan |
54 | SA702 | FTI Flyer | Charger 33 | Keith Mattison |
55 | SA264 | Spirit | Miura | Mike Phillips |
56 | SA569 | Gremlin | Spirit 28 Mod | Eva / Alan Versfeld |
57 | SA 2676 | Lets Go | Buccaneer | Duncan Johnson |
58 | 44 | Hors D'Oeuvre | L26 | P Bam |
59 | SA 141 | Chantecler | Roberts 45 | Ralph Mothes |
dns | 005 | Sensation | L34 | Michael Moore |
dnf | SA2462 | Charisma | Sadler 32 | F Booyse |
dns | SA2773 | Naledi | J120 | Felix Scheder-Bieschin |
1st Team
TEAM | |
Gil Eanes | |
Yacht | Points |
Celine IV | 29 |
Always Well | 21 |
Iechyd Da | 5 |
Impact | 35 |
Isla | 3 |
Necessity | 8 |
Ray of Light | 17 |
Jacana | 4 |
Discards | -64 |
1 | 58 |
2nd Team
TEAM | |
Infante Don Henrique | |
Yacht | Points |
Chen | 9 |
Lets Go | 57 |
Saoirse | 2 |
Indaba | 11 |
Nuthr Witch | 32 |
Touch 'n Go | 39 |
Majimoto II | 42 |
Far Med | 1 |
Discards | -99 |
2 | 94 |
3rd Team
TEAM | |
Fernao Magalhaes | |
Yacht | Points |
FTI Flyer | 54 |
Pants on Fire | 22 |
Ambre | 20 |
Cabaray | 28 |
Vortex | 31 |
Me2Me | 40 |
Maestro | 6 |
Puma Unleashed | 13 |
Discards | -85 |
3 | 129 |
4th Team
TEAM | |
Antonio De Saldanha | |
Yacht | Points |
Sizwe | 46 |
Zeal o Cat | 51 |
Southern Cross | 49 |
Storm | 18 |
Tally Ho | 33 |
Mini Mace | 44 |
Lobelia | 12 |
Windpower | 7 |
Discards | -100 |
4 | 160 |
5th Team
TEAM | |
Diogo Cao | |
Yacht | Points |
Charisma | 62 |
Spindrift | 53 |
Chantecler | 59 |
Paragon | 25 |
Hillbilly | 16 |
Rockstar | 15 |
Sheshisa | 30 |
Vodoo | 41 |
Discards | -121 |
5 | 180 |
6th Team
TEAM | |
Bartholomew Dias | |
Yacht | Points |
Spirit | 55 |
Siesta | 52 |
Ariel | 24 |
Carousel | 48 |
Lapwing | 19 |
A-L | 14 |
Spilhaus | 10 |
63 | |
Discards | -118 |
6 | 222 |
7th Team
TEAM | |
Pedro Alvares Cabral | |
Yacht | Points |
Pure Magic | 43 |
Aurora | 37 |
Ava | 34 |
Reaction | 50 |
Cathy R | 36 |
Freedom | 27 |
Naledi | 63 |
Picasso | 47 |
Discards | -110 |
7 | 227 |
8th Team
TEAM | |
Vasco Da Gama | |
Yacht | Points |
Paprika | 45 |
Corum | 23 |
Gremlin | 56 |
Hors D'Oeuvre | 58 |
Sensation | 60 |
Regent Express | 26 |
Auto Atlantic Thunderchild | 38 |
Vodoo | 41 |
Discards | -114 |
8 | 233 |
(Phew! At least we weren't part of the discard group on our team)
Oh well. You cant win 'em all, can you.